Time-outs harm children's emotional development
Is this true? Make your call, then see what the science says.
Short answer: It depends. The evidence is mixed.
There is no good evidence that time-out used calmly and properly harms emotional development. Poorly done time-out is linked to worse outcomes, and Australian child health guidance warns against isolating children. How it is done matters.
AI-generated summary of the research cited · not reviewed by a medical professional · checked 3 November 2026 · How we checkWhat the research found
A 2008 meta-analysis of 77 parent training program evaluations, covering children aged 0 to 7, found that programs teaching parents to use time-out tended to have larger effects on behaviour. That tells us about behaviour, not emotional wellbeing directly.
A nationally representative Australian survey of 474 parents of children aged 6 to 8 found that appropriately used time-out was linked to better mental health and attachment. Time-out that was not done appropriately was linked to worse outcomes. Children who had faced adversity seemed to gain the most attachment benefit from well-done time-out. This was a one-off survey, so it shows links, not cause and effect.
A 2020 study followed children from Early Head Start families over time to look at time-out and emotional and behavioural outcomes. Its authors noted that time-out is often called harmful in popular media, yet research on its side effects is limited.
What it doesn’t mean
- This does not mean all time-out is fine. Child health guidance for toddlers and for school-age children says isolating a child can be harmful or increase distress, and it stresses comfort, connection and clear, consistent boundaries.
- Research on possible side effects of time-out is limited, and the Australian survey shows links rather than cause and effect. It cannot fully rule out harm in some children or situations.
- If your child's behaviour is intense, ongoing or affecting daily life, talk to your GP or another health professional.
Sources
General information only, not medical advice. KIDS fact-checks are generated by AI from published research and are not reviewed by doctors or other health professionals. They can be wrong or out of date. Always talk to your GP or child’s doctor about your child, and call 000 in an emergency. Spotted a problem? Tell us.
Check the next one in the app
New claims every day. Guess first, see the science, compare with other parents.
Get KIDS for iPhone