Shouting at teenagers is as harmful as smacking
Is this true? Make your call, then see what the science says.
Short answer: It depends. The evidence is mixed.
Child health guidance says to avoid both shouting and physical discipline with teens because each can cause distress and harm the relationship. Nothing found compares the two, so 'as harmful as' is unproven.
AI-generated summary of the research cited · not reviewed by a medical professional · checked 5 November 2026 · How we checkWhat the research found
Australian child health guidance for teens says to avoid physical discipline, shouting or shaming. It says these responses can make teens more distressed and are likely to harm the relationship. Guidance for younger children also lists shouting alongside physical discipline as harmful.
A 2019 JAMA news report said the American Academy of Pediatrics advised against both spanking and harsh verbal discipline. That shows health bodies treat the two as problems to avoid. It does not show they cause the same amount of harm.
A 2018 meta-analysis of 14 trials of a parenting program in Europe (1,799 participants) found parents reported less corporal punishment and less shouting after the program. That shows these habits can change. It does not measure how much harm each one does to teens.
What it doesn’t mean
- This does not mean shouting is safe. Guidance says it can raise a teen's distress and strain the relationship, so staying calm is the better approach.
- Nothing found compares the size of harm from shouting and from smacking in teenagers. Treat 'equally harmful' as unproven rather than false.
- If conflict at home feels intense or is affecting daily life, talk to a GP or another health professional about support.
Sources
General information only, not medical advice. KIDS fact-checks are generated by AI from published research and are not reviewed by doctors or other health professionals. They can be wrong or out of date. Always talk to your GP or child’s doctor about your child, and call 000 in an emergency. Spotted a problem? Tell us.
Check the next one in the app
New claims every day. Guess first, see the science, compare with other parents.
Get KIDS for iPhone