Spanking children harms their development
Is this true? Make your call, then see what the science says.
Short answer: Yes. The evidence supports this.
Many reviews link spanking to worse behaviour, mental health and development in children, and paediatric guidance advises against it. Most studies are observational, and effects after careful adjustment can be small, so cause and effect is less certain.
AI-generated summary of the research cited · not reviewed by a medical professional · checked 3 November 2026 · How we checkWhat the research found
A 2016 meta-analysis covering 160,927 children found that 13 of 17 average effect sizes pointed to a link between spanking and worse outcomes. The links were similar across study designs. A 2002 meta-analysis found corporal punishment was linked with more aggression and poorer mental health. A 2023 systematic review of 34 articles also examined early childhood development.
Large surveys in low- and middle-income countries point the same way. In 49 countries, children aged 36 to 59 months who were physically punished were about 24% less likely to be developmentally on track. Another survey of 215,885 children in 62 countries linked spanking to lower socioemotional scores in 3- and 4-year-olds.
The strength of the harm is debated. A 2013 meta-analysis of long-term studies found small links, but when it controlled for earlier behaviour the effects were statistically significant yet trivial. A 2018 analysis found a small risk or a small benefit depending on the method used. A 2022 review reported strong associations, with culture affecting the results.
What it doesn’t mean
- Most of this research is observational. It shows spanking is linked with worse outcomes, not that it alone causes them. Children who are harder to manage may also be spanked more.
- Effects look small in the best-controlled studies, and culture may change how spanking affects children. That does not show spanking is helpful or safe.
- Paediatric guidance says to avoid spanking, and notes that punishment of children under 18 months raises the chance of physical injury. If discipline is becoming harsh or hard to manage, talk to a GP or child health nurse.
Sources
General information only, not medical advice. KIDS fact-checks are generated by AI from published research and are not reviewed by doctors or other health professionals. They can be wrong or out of date. Always talk to your GP or child’s doctor about your child, and call 000 in an emergency. Spotted a problem? Tell us.
Check the next one in the app
New claims every day. Guess first, see the science, compare with other parents.
Get KIDS for iPhone