Smacking makes children better behaved
Is this true? Make your call, then see what the science says.
Short answer: No. The evidence doesn’t support this.
Smacking may get a child to comply in the moment, but research does not show it improves behaviour over time. Large reviews link it with more aggression and other problems, and child health guidance says to avoid physical discipline.
AI-generated summary of the research cited · not reviewed by a medical professional · checked 3 November 2026 · How we checkWhat the research found
A 2016 meta-analysis pooled 111 effect sizes covering 160,927 children. Thirteen of 17 average results linked spanking with a higher risk of harmful outcomes. A 2002 meta-analysis found spanking went with more immediate compliance, but also more aggression and poorer mental health and moral development.
Cause and effect is hard to pin down. A 2018 meta-analysis of long-term studies (children aged 18 months to 11 years) found a small risk or a small benefit of spanking for later behaviour problems, depending on the method used. An older 2000 review found some benefits in clinical studies of 2- to 6-year-olds, mainly when mild spanking backed up other discipline. It also found harm from frequent use.
One study of aggressive fifth graders found that children who got less physical punishment showed fewer callous, unemotional traits over time. Warmth and involvement from parents predicted improvements in antisocial behaviour.
What it doesn’t mean
- Short-term compliance is not the same as better behaviour. Studies that found quick compliance also found more aggression and lower wellbeing.
- Most of this research is observational, so it cannot fully prove smacking causes harm. Even so, the overall direction is consistent, and child health guidance advises against physical discipline for toddlers and teens.
- If your child's behaviour is intense, ongoing or affecting daily life, talk to your GP or child health nurse about other ways to guide behaviour.
Sources
General information only, not medical advice. KIDS fact-checks are generated by AI from published research and are not reviewed by doctors or other health professionals. They can be wrong or out of date. Always talk to your GP or child’s doctor about your child, and call 000 in an emergency. Spotted a problem? Tell us.
Check the next one in the app
New claims every day. Guess first, see the science, compare with other parents.
Get KIDS for iPhone